It seems that the Custom 404 plugin does not let me have the custom layout apply to my 404 page I built. It defaults to the stack and not one of my custom layout pages. I am using Icon Stack. I set the template to apply to the specific page and it refuses to do it. The rest of my site looks one way, and the 404 page looks different.
It is disappointing because it is not inline with the look and feel of the rest of the site. Any idea why this can’t happen?