Hey @slwirth,
@Rad has pointed out that this is not an issue with the theme. And, I also have tested the free version of Caldera Forms in my test site and it just works out of the box. @mldarshana just confirmed it (He didn’t mean that we support third party conflicts though). You also have confirmed this is not a theme issue when you said it works in your other site.
This means that, there is something that is causing this in your site. I’m sorry but we did what we could here. We only can go as far as finding if it’s caused by the theme and we found that it is not.
At this point, you will need to contact the Caldera Forms support. We can help you no further.
Thank you for understanding.