Hello Matt,
Thanks for writing in! When you log in to your site, you will be seeing this:
Your site is running an outdated, insecure version of PHP (7.0.33-47+ubuntu18.04.1+deb.sury.org+1), which could be putting your site at risk for being hacked. WordPress is working towards discontinuing support for your PHP version. Updating PHP only takes a few minutes and will make your website significantly faster and more secure. Learn more about updating PHP
You can also go to Tools > Site Health > Status and see that there are issues in your WP installation. Please resolve it first. This is to avoid any Error 500 when activating the X theme and Cornerstone plugin. You may need to check out this compatibility documentation first for further details:
Kindly let us know how it goes.